Forgiving the Unforgivable – A Soul Perspective
by Dottie Titus


How does one forgive a hurt that has left scars for 40 years? The incest was so insidious. It began with little pats and caresses that seemed almost innocent. I was only 5. Something didn't feel right, but he always had an answer.

"If it's okay for me to pat you on top of the blankets, why is it wrong to put my hand under the blanket to pat you?" My 5-year-old mind couldn't find an answer. There was just this awful feeling....

The patting progressed to fondling, then to more intimate liberties as I grew older. When I was about 8, I tried to object more firmly. When he made my little brother go to bed for a nap and then told me to come into his bedroom, I said no. He insisted. I said no. Our voices got louder until my little brother came out of his room and asked why he was grabbing me. He was furious. He hit my brother and yelled at him to go back to bed and not come out. The lesson was clear to me: Submit or others will be hurt. I submitted.

Finally, when I was about 12 years old, I told my mother what had been going on. She was shocked. Nobody spoke of incest in the 1950s. After a day and a half of yelling and fighting (he denied everything), she said to me, "I'm going to ask you if what you told me is true. If you say it is, I'll take you and your brother and we'll leave him. I don't know how we'll survive, but we'll manage. But I want you to understand it will all be your fault."

This huge crisis

I know now that she was scared. She was pretty isolated back then. The women in the neighborhood scorned her because she was a working mother. In fact, some of them wouldn't let their children play with us solely because of that. They said she was "unfit." She was scared, alone and facing this huge crisis. She wanted to be sure I was telling the truth, so she made the price of lying very high. But what I heard was that the family would be broken up, disaster would result, and it would be my fault. I only wanted the incest to stop! So I told her that I had lied.

Fortunately, the incest did indeed stop, but it was a self-betrayal of huge proportions. And he changed. Outwardly, he was still as vocal with sexual innuendoes and jokes, but he stopped taking care of himself and his health began to suffer.

For the next 40 years, I hated him. I painted a picture of this man as a self-centered, cruel S.O.B. who had wanted to hurt me. How could I ever forgive him for what he did to me?

Over those years, I also convinced myself that the incest had caused me no real harm. I was fine. I had a healthy libido, and I liked men. In fact, I got along better with men than with women. No harm done.

Then, in my late 30s, I began to have trouble working with male bosses. A friend suggested I see a therapist. I found an alternative healer who did therapy, and eventually I found myself enrolling in The Pathwork, an intense, five-year program of self-growth and transformation. My healing had begun.

It wasn't easy work. I spent a lot of time ranting about what had happened, blaming him and putting out my anger by hitting a pillow, kicking on a mattress, screaming, and even re-enacting the scene with a caring helper. This time, I was strong enough to keep him away from me. But still I hated. When I went home for visits, I couldn't wait to get away, because he was there.

The first crack
The first crack in my hatred came when I read Pat Rodegast's book Emmanuel: A Manual for Living Comfortably in the Cosmos. In it, someone asked Emmanuel why children had to suffer from things such as cruelty and incest. Emmanuel's answer was that sometimes a soul took on such a life task in order to help another soul grow. Oh, I loved hearing this. My beautiful soul had taken on this onerous task just to help him. How very loving and generous of me!!! I went from victim to martyr in a heartbeat!

The shift in perspective was important. It opened the way for me to consider that my soul chose to have this experience for a purpose, a concept that is basic to the Pathwork, which stresses self-responsibility and understanding cause and effect. I began to turn from blaming him to looking at why such an experience was important for me. And I quickly found the answer. There was a part of me that refused to love and trust. As I remembered some of the family stories about my childhood, I realized that this refusal did not grow out of the incest, but it was something I brought into this lifetime with me. It was evident long before the incest began. It was my life task, what I was here to heal.

As I began to heal this part of me, the hatred began to ease a little. I still felt contempt for him, but I could bear to be around him for occasional visits. Then he was diagnosed with lung cancer. The doctors said he had six months to live.

A wonderful soul
One day, I was thinking about the martyr role again. What a wonderful soul I was to take on a horrific task like enduring incest to help another soul. At that point, I heard spirit speak. It was clear as could be. The words were, "Or vice versa." Martyrdom was shattered. Victim was shattered. Was it possible that his soul had taken on such a horrible role to help my soul grow? To help me realize that I was unwilling to love? I was shaken down to my core. The next step of my healing had begun.

I worked with this deeply over the next few months. His condition worsened, but he hung on. Twelve months after he was diagnosed, I finally wrote to him and spoke my forgiveness. In 40 years, we had never talked about what had happened. Now I spoke from my heart, telling him of my scars and the healing I still had to do, being clear that I was not condoning what he had done, but I had reached the point where I could forgive him. I spoke of my regret for the way we both had punished him for all those years.

He didn't respond to my letter right away, but three months later, when he was in the hospital with difficulty breathing, he wrote back to me. He thanked me and told me he had always loved me. He thanked me for understanding him and said he never meant to hurt me. It was our last communication. He died shortly after that.

At the funeral, I was surprised that I could cry. I discovered there was still a little girl inside who was grieving his loss. As I comforted that inner child, I knew that forgiveness had truly happened.

There are still some scars, although far fewer now. Every so often, when I notice that I am not being trusting of a man, I have to check in and see if that distrust is coming out of my history. I feel grateful for the tremendous healing that forgiveness has brought to me. All that hatred was too heavy to keep carrying.

Dottie Titus is a Pathwork Helper in the Twin Cities area. She can be reached at (612) 522-4545 or by e-mail at
DottieT@aol.com.
Copyright (c) 2002 Dottie Titus


Aug 2002


The EDGE is a leading source in the United States for inspiration, education and information related to personal growth, integrative healing and global transformation.